CARI Captures 451: Vietnam and Laos lead region in COVID-19 response stringency index



 

ASEAN

ASEAN-5 countries projected to grow in 2021
(20 April 2020) Vietnam and Laos lead ASEAN countries with a score of 100 as of 18 April, in the COVID-19 Government Response Stringency Index published by the University of Oxford’s Blavatnik School of Government. The two countries are followed by the Philippines, Malaysia and Thailand which share the same score of 85.71. Brunei, which has among the lowest cases of COVID-19 in the region comes in the last spot with a score of 57.14. The scores are based on measurements of seven response indicators, which include school and workplace closures, travel bans, public event cancellations, public transport closures, public information campaigns and movement restrictions. The Blavatnik School of Government notes that a higher position in the index does not necessarily mean that a country’s response is “better” than others lower on the index and that the index was released to help decision makers and public health professionals examine the robustness of government responses

ASEAN

Dialogue partners working towards signing of RCEP in Vietnam in late 2020
(18 April 2020) Dialogue partners of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) are advancing the review of legal texts, with an expectation of the process to finish in July 2020 so that the pact can be signed at the ASEAN Summit in Vietnam in late 2020 as scheduled, according to Auramon Supthaweethum, director-general of the Trade Negotiations Department under Thailand’s Ministry of Commerce. The working panel handling the legal text-scrubbing for the pact has already finished six chapters and is working on the remaining 14 chapters. The next video conference of the RCEP Trade Negotiation Committee is scheduled for 20-24 April. The agreement has been scheduled for official signing in 2020, and is expected to come into force either in 2021 or January 2022. Auramon said signing the RCEP is crucial to the region, especially with the pandemic delivering a heavy blow to the world’s economy.

BRUNEI

Brunei considers cutting oil output in line with OPEC+ pact
(22 April 2020) Brunei will review cutting its oil output in view of its cooperation with OPEC, second minister of finance Mohd Amin Liew Abdullah said on 21 April. This comes after OPEC and allies led by Russia, a group known as OPEC+, agreed on 12 April on historic production cuts that could curb global supply by up to 20% and prop up oil prices. According to Amin, the government is in discussions with Brunei Shell Petroleum and OPEC to see how it can help stabilise the global oil market. Since the COVID-19 outbreak began, global fuel demand has fallen by 30%, as steps to fight the pandemic have grounded planes, cut vehicle usage and curbed economic activity. However, the second finance minister was optimistic Brunei could still offload its oil shipments.

MALAYSIA

Malaysian bonds one of Asia’s top performers, but oil prices may weigh on them
(24 April 2020) Malaysia’s bonds have been one of Asia’s top performers behind the Philippines in April 2020, with the yield on the benchmark 10-year security dropping by 40 basis points. Demand for Malaysian government debt has been boosted by expectations that the central bank will lower its overnight policy rate by at least another 25 basis points in the coming months to help cushion the impact of COVID-19. However, the slump in oil prices may weigh on bond prices, with Malaysia deriving some 20% of its revenue from the energy market. The government is forecasting a deficit of about 4% of GDP in 2020.

INDONESIA

Indonesia to restrict all passenger travel starting 24 April to prevent Idul Fitri exodus
(24 April 2020) The Indonesian government will restrict all passenger travel starting on 24 April as the government attempts to prevent the Idul Fitri tradition of mudik (exodus) to contain the spread of COVID-19. The ban will not apply to the transportation of cargo nor vehicles serving special purposes such as ambulances and fire trucks. The ban will apply to vehicles entering and leaving regions that had imposed large-scale social restrictions and those that had been declared COVID-19 red zones. Air transportation to domestic and international destinations will be stopped until 1 June, while restrictions on land transport will last until 31 May. All train services until 15 June will be cancelled, while passenger transportation by sea will be suspended until 8 June.

INDONESIA

Government to provide interest subsidy for small business borrowers
(22 April 2020) The Indonesian government announced that it will provide interest subsidies for small business borrowers in banks and finance companies to help them cope with the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. According to finance minister Sri Mulyani Indrawati, the government, the Financial Services Authority (OJK) and Bank Indonesia (BI) were currently finalising the regulations in response to President Joko Widodo’s call for financial assistance for small businesses. The subsidy will be designed for individuals as well as micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) with the financing capped at US$32,269 (Rp 500 million), which is the credit limit in the government’s microcredit programme (KUR). Cooperatives and Small and Medium Enterprises Ministry acting finance deputy Hanung Harimba Rachman estimated that 70% of the total existing KUR entities will be able to join a business restructuring programme with the government’s interest subsidy.

THAILAND

Finance Ministry to issue promissory notes worth US$2.2 billion
(23 April 2020) Thailand’s Finance Ministry will issue promissory notes (PN) worth US$2.2 billion (70 billion baht) as the first batch of borrowing under the US$30.8 billion (1 trillion baht) royal decree to mitigate the impact from the COVID-19 outbreak and the government’s containment measures. The Public Debt Management Office (PDMO) initially planned to offer 70 billion baht worth of PNs with maturity of four years based on the Bangkok Interbank Offered Rate (Bibor), which stood at 0.97%. The PDMO will allow commercial banks to make the bidding on 28 April, according to PDMO director-general Patricia Mongkhonvanit. The proceeds obtained from the PNs will be used to fund the US$154 (5,000 baht) cash handout in its second month and the ministry must receive the raised funds before 5 May to add to treasury reserves

THE PHILIPPINES

Remittance flows to the Philippines may decline by more than a fifth in 2020
(23 April 2020) Remittance flows to the Philippines may decline by more 20% in 2020 as Filipinos working abroad lose employment while the world economy faces the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2019, remittances from overseas Filipino workers rose by 4.0% to US$35.2 billion. The World Bank noted year-on-year growth in remittances to the Philippines for January and February 2020 was 4.8% and 4.4%, respectively and that remittances may decline by 20% to 30% in 2020. This would see a corresponding growth rate of 2.0% for the year 2020. The World Bank noted that during economic crises in host countries, remittance flows can decrease, as was the case during the 2008 Financial Crisis, which saw remittance flows to low- and middle-income countries decline by 5.0%.

THE PHILIPPINES

World Bank approves US$100 million loan to the Philippines
(23 April 2020) The World Bank has approved a US$100 million loan to the Philippines for its COVID-19 emergency response project to help meet urgent healthcare needs. The project will help strengthen the country’s healthcare delivery system for critical medical services in the face of increased demand in the coming months. According to the World Bank, the project will focus on providing personal protective equipment (PPE), drugs, medical supplies, medical devices, laboratory equipment, and test kits. Apart from that, the response project will also support the Department of Health in preparing guidance on standard design for hospital isolation and treatment centres to manage COVID-19. The expansion of the Philippines’ laboratory capacity will also be funded by the project.

CAMBODIA

New factories opened in the first quarter of 2020 despite COVID-19 pandemic
(23 April 2020) A total of 77 new factories, including 34 garment, footwear, and travel goods factories, opened in Cambodia in the first quarter of 2020 despite the COVID-19 pandemic. According to the Ministry of Industry, Science, Technology, and Innovation, the new factories created jobs for 27,909 people. Although many factories have seen a drop in purchasing orders, it is believed demand will resume once the pandemic passes. Most of the garment, footwear and travel goods factories continued to operate due to constant supply of raw materials from China, with only six factories having permanently shut down during the quarter affecting some 6,052 workers. Cambodia’s exports of garment, footwear, and travel goods in 2019 was valued at US$9.32 billion, accounting for over 83% of the country’s total industrial product exports.

Mekong Monitor: Vietnam establishes anti-panic commodities trading floor amid pandemic


Photo credit: vnshop.vn

 

TRADE, ECONOMY, AND INVESTMENT

 

VIETNAM

Vietnam establishes anti-panic commodities trading floor amid pandemic
(19 April 2020) Vietnam has established an anti-panic commodities trading floor to boost e-commerce and help the public purchase necessities at a stable price. The trading floor vnshop.vn was launched by CIB Corporation on 18 April and will be managed by Vietnam’s Ministry of Industry and Trade. It will assist local authorities, manufacturing companies, logistic companies and consumers by mitigating false demand and supply fluctuations. According to CIB Corporation CEO Albert Ma, if there is any demand for necessities, consumers can pre-order online in a limited quantity and the orders are guaranteed to be supplied by manufacturing enterprises in a timely manner. He added that keeping the demands transparent can avoid psychological panic during the COVID-19 pandemic and regulate real supply-demand to avoid social waste.
Read more>>

THAILAND, VIETNAM

Thai energy firm invests US$456.7 million in solar power plants in Vietnam
(21 April 2020) Thailand-listed Super Energy Corporation Public Company Limited will invest US$456.7 million in four solar power plants in Vietnam’s southeastern province of Binh Phuoc, the company said in a regulatory filing to the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The four solar power plants are expected to have a total installed capacity of 750 megawatts and estimated to produce returns on investment of around 17% for each plant. The Vietnamese government currently gives priority to solar and wind energy to reduce environmental impacts and to build energy security for the country. Binh Phuoc province is expected to become one of the country’s largest solar energy producers as it has high potential for solar electricity, particularly in Loc Ninh district where the intensity of solar radiation, at 5.14 KWh per square metre per day, is higher than other places in the region.
Read more>>

LAOS

Lao government to consider compensation for unemployed workers
(22 April 2020) Employees who are members of their companies’ social insurance scheme may be eligible to receive about US$56 (500,000 kip) from the National Social Security Fund (NSSF) as part of measures to help people affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, according to Lao deputy minister of Labour and Social Welfare, Padeumphone Sonthany. If implemented, the NSSF will pay compensation to unemployed workers for a two-month period in May and June. The businesses heavily affected by the closure under the current lockdown are processing and garment factories, construction material manufacturers, restaurants and shops, as well as businesses related to the special and specific economic zones. The proposal is one among several that was put forward by businesses and will be tabled at the cabinet’s monthly meeting scheduled for 23 April.
Read more>>

CAMBODIA

Tax exemption for hotels, guesthouses extended to more provinces
(21 April 2020) The Cambodian government has given a three-month tax exemption to hotels, guesthouses, restaurants and travel agencies in Phnom Penh and several provinces as the tourism industry feels the pinch from the COVID-19 pandemic. According to Tith Chantha, a secretary of state at the Ministry of Tourism, the tax exemption was made in line with the government’s measures aimed at assisting the private sector and workers affected by the pandemic. The tax exemption for March until May 2020 are for hotels, guesthouses, restaurants and travel agencies located in Phnom Penh, Siem Reap, Preah Sihanouk, Kep, Kampot, Bavet city and Poipet city, which are registered with the General Department of Taxation. Earlier in February, the government announced a monthly tax exemption from February to May for hotels and guesthouses in Siem Reap province only.
Read more>>

VIETNAM

Rice export continues despite pandemic
(21 April 2020) Vietnam’s deputy prime minister Trinh Dinh Dung on 20 April ordered the advancing of the export quota of 100,000 tonnes of rice, which was set for May 2020, in order to ease difficulties for firms that have rice stuck at ports but are unable to submit customs declarations. After chairing a meeting on rice export during the COVID-19 outbreak, Dung said glutinous rice can be exported as normal. He added that the Ministry of Industry and Trade has been assigned to coordinate with the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development to review and assess the domestic supply and demand of rice to manage the export. In the current situation, rice export must be carefully considered against national food security and the protection of the legal rights of farmers and relevant organisations.
Read more>>

 


mekong-monitor-map

About Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS)

The Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) Economic Programme was launched by the Asian Development Bank in 1992 connecting five developing ASEAN countries, namely Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Vietnam and Thailand, and Chinese provinces of Yunnan and Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous region. The region has some of the most robust economies sharing the Mekong River Basin thanks to its reform and liberalisation. The subregion is growing at a faster pace than the whole of East Asia and the Asia Pacific as the GDP growth rate for 2017 was at 6.4 percent, according to the World Bank. The population at the subregion as of 2016 is at 340 million while the GDP at PPP is at US$3.1 trillion in 2016. In 2015, trading within the region was at US$444 billion.

China-ASEAN Monitor: Online trade fair between Vietnam and Guangxi province opens


Photo Credit: China Daily

 

Economy, Investment and Trade

 

Online trade fair between Vietnam and Guangxi province opens
(21 April 2020) An online trade fair between Vietnam and China’s Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region opened on 21 April, according to Guangxi’s commerce department. The three-day event will feature more than 70 kinds of commodities such as nuts, fruits, and seafood. Enterprises from both countries intend to purchase US$86.1 million worth of commodities. Guangxi’s import and export trade volume with Vietnam reached US$24.7 billion in 2019, with Vietnam having been Guangxi’s largest trading partner for 21 consecutive years. Another trade fair with Vietnam is expected to be held in May.
Read more>>

Vietnam’s total exports to China in first quarter of 2020 increases by 24%
(20 April 2020) Vietnam’s total exports to China by value in the first quarter of 2020 reached US$9.3 billion, a 24% increase year-on-year. The export value in March alone reached US$3.9 billion, a 22.3% increase year-on-year. Two groups of export goods, phones and components; and computers, electronic products and components, each achieved export values above US$1 billion. Agricultural products, however, saw a sharp decline within the same quarter. The import of goods from China reached US$16.2 billion, a decrease of US$50 million compared to the same period last year. China was Vietnam’s largest trading partner within the quarter, accounting for 20.8% of Vietnams’ total trade.
Read more>>

Guangdong trade with ASEAN grows by 7.7% in first quarter of 2020
(21 April 2020) Guangdong province saw its trade with ASEAN countries grow by 7.7% year-on-year in the first quarter of 2020. The province’s total trade volume in the first quarter dropped by 11.8% year-on-year to US$193 billion, with exports down 14.4% and imports down 7.8% year-on-year. ASEAN was Guangdong’s largest trading partner in the first quarter, with the trade volume accounting for 16% of the province’s total trade. According to the province’s customs official, Guangdong’s foreign trade gradually improved in March as the COVID-19 pandemic subsided within China.
Read more>>

Chinese tourists indicate they would like to travel to Thailand sometime in 2020
(21 April 2020) The China Thailand Travel Sentiment Survey 2020 conducted in mid-April found that 53% of Chinese tourists would like to travel sometime this year, with August, October, and December in particular seen as preferred dates to travel. More than two thirds (71%) of these respondents prefer to travel to Thailand, with Bangkok, Phuket, and Chiang Mai ranked as the top three destinations. Chinese tourists totalled almost 11 million in 2019, more than one-fourth of Thailand’s overall 39.8 million international arrivals. A weakening baht vis-a-vis the yuan as well as a resumption of aviation activities in China may encourage a return of Chinese tourists to Thailand.
Read more>>

Thai-listed manufacturing companies may benefit from resumption of economic activities in China
(11 April 2020) At least 45 Thai listed companies in the manufacturing sector will benefit from the resumption of economic activities in China. At the end of 2019, 45 companies in the production sector listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand were doing business with China, and are to benefit from a resumption of bilateral trade and supply chain activity. Thai exports to China were worth US$29 billion (12% of Thai exports worldwide), while Thai imports from China were worth US$50 billion (worth 21% of total imports). As of 26 March, these listed companies had a total market capitalisation worth US$74 billion (20% of the Stock Exchange of Thailand).
Read more>>

ASEAN in crisis and its preparedness against COVID-19

Originally published in TheEdge Malaysia, 20 April – 26 April 2020 edition.

The Association of Southeast Asian Nations or ASEAN, established through the ASEAN Declaration of 8 August 1967 identifies its roots based on accelerating economic growth through the promotion of coordinated regional actions and initiatives – most importantly for regional peace, as the region faced a common fear of communism at the time of ASEAN’s interception. Fast-forward 53 years, and ASEAN member states today face the COVID-19 pandemic as their common enemy; and at the time of writing, the number of cases in the region had exceeded 18,994.1

This article attempts to examine how effective the regional bloc has been in collaborating pandemic preparedness and protocols, and the need for the region to refocus its 2020 lens at decentralised and autonomous production this year to lessen the impact of over-reliance on the global supply chains.

ASEAN’s coordinated initiatives

Several initiatives and actions have been set up by the ASEAN health sector to share technical expertise, risk reports, data analyses, and to ensure the maintenance of international health regulations and standards. (see table)

Regional mechanisms in the ASEAN health sector2

Mechanism ASEAN Member State
ASEAN Plus Three Senior Officials Meeting for Health Development (APT SOMHD) Cambodia
ASEAN Public Health Emergency Operations Centre (PHEOC) Network Malaysia
ASEAN Plus Three Field Epidemiology Training Network (ASEAN+3 FETN) Chaired: Malaysia
Coordinated by Thailand
ASEAN BioDiaspora Virtual Centre for big data analytics and visualisation (ABVC) The Philippines
ASEAN Risk Assessment and Risk Communication Centre (ARARC) Malaysia
Public health laboratories network under the purview of ASEAN Health Cluster 2 on Responding to All Hazards and Emerging Threats All Member States
Regional Public Health Laboratories Network (RPHL) Thailand



Be that as it may, it can be said that from the outbreak of the pandemic, each member state has had to generate their own protocols in terms of social distancing measures, border controls, and suitable economic stimulus to be put in place.

We recognise that ASEAN is made up of diverse economies at various market maturities. However, as ZICOlaw being present in all ten ASEAN countries, we have Regional mechanisms in the ASEAN health sector contract interpretations, force majeure and employer obligations. We have seen that regardless of common, civil or hybrid legal systems of the ten ASEAN jurisdictions, shared opinion and response can be found which allowed us to adopt a common protocol for our clients. Invariably this also applies to how our ASEAN leaders could have better resolved common difficulties and challenges across the region.

The pandemic’s economic impact is heightened given ASEAN’s reliance on China as its second-largest trading partner. While ASEAN states have each issued a variety of fiscal and non-fiscal measures to soften the short-term impact of the pandemic, there appears to be a vacuum in terms of strong leadership for coordinated efforts in the region. It could be said that a region-wide streamlined response framework, or agreed protocols could be better coordinated and put in place instead of the current ad-hoc approach which gave rise to issues like stranded employees and supply chain disruptions.

Social distancing, movement control orders and border controls

As early as 30 January 2020,3 the World Health Organization had identified social distancing as a necessary action to flatten the curve and combat further transmission of the virus. Among the ASEAN countries, the quick and bold actions by the Philippines and Malaysia governments instituting movement and mobility control orders within its shores were arguably, hard decisions made. Further control orders were then instituted requiring borders to close, first partially, thereafter fully, where all overseas travel and arrivals were curbed. While this is commended, it is important to recognise the mobility of ASEAN citizens working within the region. A good example is the reliance on Malaysia’s workforce in Singapore – and the ad-hoc announcement between the two countries on 18 March 20204 and 23 March 20205 respectively, that resulted in confusion and chaos at border control checkpoints. In this regard, closer coordination by Malaysia and Singapore leaders would have been more ideal and effective.

China-reliance and supply chain disruptions

As ASEAN’s second-largest trading partner, with China being closed for most of Q1 2020, it is vital for ASEAN leaders to come together earlier to address supply chain disruptions and the need to self-supply. While globalisation and the co-dependency of an efficient global supply chain has fuelled the growth of ASEAN in recent decades, the lesson learned from these border controls is surely the fragility of the system itself.

We agree that implementing border controls and travel bans are essential. However, overly stringent measures can cause disruptions in supply chains which rely heavily on the movement of goods. In this regard, a delicate balance has to be kept between implementing overarching protectionist measures and preserving national health and safety.

In the ASEAN region, many strong ASEAN brands and businesses could pull together to fill the gap left by China. For example, the world’s biggest medical gloves manufacturer by volume, Top Glove Corp in Malaysia could have, without interruption, continued manufacturing 200 million gloves a day, but had to halt until its packaging suppliers obtained the requisite approval to operate following the shutdown under Malaysia’s movement control order6. A deeper study on the supply and demand capabilities that can be resourced within ASEAN may prove useful to ensure a more self-reliant region, both in times of prosperity and crisis.

Conclusion

Fifty-three years is a considerable amount of time, as an economic block, to have reached some maturity at coming together in a crisis. Past crises would be useful parameters for some measure of preparedness and protocols that can be commonly adopted. Close communication at times of isolation is key, and future focus on self-producing for ASEAN-made and ASEAN-reliant goods, would help further propel the region’s growth in terms of sustainability and creativity.



1 Outbreak.my
2 ASEAN Health Sector Efforts in the Prevention, Detection and Response to Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
3 Statement on the second meeting of the International Health Regulations (2005) Emergency Committee regarding the outbreak of novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV), WHO
4 PM Muhyiddin calls on people to remain resilient, continue obeying MCO, Prime Minister's Office of Malaysia Official Website
5 Coronavirus: An unprecedented Singapore border closure, in unprecedented times, The Straits Times
6 COVID-19 fight at risk as Malaysia’s medical glove makers struggle with lockdown, CNA




Hanim Hamzah is Regional Managing Partner of ZICOlaw Network, the only premier law firm network with offices in all 10 ASEAN countries. The network comprises independent leading law firms with a full presence in 18 cities across Southeast Asia, a region of over 650 million people and 10 countries. This article represents the author’s opinion and does not necessarily reflect that of the ZICOlaw Network. It also does not serve as substitute for specialist legal advice.

Press Release: COVID-19 Pandemic: ASEAN must address short-term relief and long-term survival for businesses while well placed to thrive on post-pandemic regionalism


ASEAN’s economic policy responses to COVID-19 must address short-term relief and long-term survival for businesses while ASEAN is well placed to thrive on post-pandemic trade regionalisation with true economic integration


Clockwise starting from top left: Shinta Widjaja Kamdani, CEO of Sintesa Group Indonesia; Arin Jira, Chairman of the Map Ta Phut Industrial Gasses Co Ltd Thailand; Chua Soon Ghee, Partner of Kearney Singapore; Jose Ma Concepcion III, President and CEO of RFM Corporation Philippines; and Tan Sri Dr. Munir Majid, Chairman of CIMB ASEAN Research Institute and President of ASEAN Business Club.

 

21 April 2020 – The first online ASEAN Roundtable Series organised by the CIMB ASEAN Research Institute (CARI) brought together business leaders from Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Indonesia to discuss the series of stimulus measures announced by several ASEAN governments in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The panellists consist of four of ASEAN’s leading business leaders and expert, Chua Soon Ghee, Partner of Kearney Singapore; Shinta Widjaja Kamdani, CEO of Sintesa Group Indonesia; Mr Arin Jira, Chairman of the Map Ta Phut Industrial Gasses Co Ltd Thailand and Jose Ma Concepcion III, President and CEO of RFM Corporation Philippines. The panel discussion was chaired by Tan Sri Dr Munir Majid, Chairman of CARI.

“We should not be in a state of COVID-19 paralysis. Yes, we must first confront the attack on health and lives. We must also, however, open up corridors to livelihoods and economic activity which have been decimated. We must find the median that makes them not mutually exclusive. This calls for imaginative policy implementation and enforcement, as well as for personal and corporate discipline,” noted Tan Sri Munir in his opening remarks.



1) Policy responses today determines long-term survival of businesses

Shinta Widjaja Kamdani said that even though there are limits to the extent of what ASEAN countries can do to save themselves from the economic damages and crisis projection caused by the pandemic, all policy responses and government spending that are aimed at alleviating financial burdens on businesses, such as reducing tax and credit burdens as well as compliance cost, will translate into survivability for business in the longer term.

“This pandemic has raised the alarm – that regulatory efficiency; the accuracy of the overall economic activities data (particularly the informal ones); interconnectivity and diversification of supply chain, both domestic and cross-border supply chains included – are capital that saves our economy in a crisis. Although the importance of these aspects may vary in each ASEAN country, some will be more pronounced than others in the long run when the industries consider their future business plans,” says Shinta, who is also the Deputy Chairman of International Relations of the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, KADIN.



2) Supply chains diversification and opportunities for ASEAN

The panellists agree that diversification of supply chains also involves reducing the region’s overdependence on Chinese manufacturers and raw materials. Disruptions in the supply of raw materials, labour, and sub-assembly components to ASEAN (particularly from China) had a significant impact on ASEAN industries.

Data shows that ASEAN manufacturers saw their worst month on record in March 2020, with the headline Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) falling from 50.2 in February to a record low of 43.4 in March. This was attributed in part to disruptions in supply chains impacting production and causing delays in deliveries.1

“The sudden China shutdown triggered a global supply chain shock and will accelerate the movement of some manufacturing from China to ASEAN and elsewhere. China has a 28% share of global manufacturing, while ASEAN is only at 4-5%. For those countries who are prepared with policy tools such as incentives and schemes, this will be a golden opportunity,” observed Chua Soon Ghee.



3) Stimulus package for MSMEs – go beyond short-term and debottlenecking the help

The panellists agreed that the stimulus measures announced by several ASEAN governments were timely. However, the assistance provided to SMEs is limited and targeted at providing support and relief in the short term.

“Most of the stimulus packages have been focused on ameliorating the pain of a sudden sharp drop in demand, through some combinations of wage assistance, fees rebates or deferrals as well as loan support. New rounds of support should go beyond the short term. With continued social distancing until a vaccine is widely available, there will be reduced demand for industries such as travel, hospitality, F&B, retail, energy, and therefore longer-term support for a year would be required,” said Chua.

He noted that critically, governments need to help SME address cash flow problems directly by providing loan support to keep SMEs afloat until demand goes back to normal. Equally important is the need to debottleneck the assistance to the SMEs due to slow flow through within the channels which are expected to distribute the benefits to downstream companies. The flow-through has been slow in many circumstances and will need to be accelerated through either moral exhortation, legislation, or direct cash to affected individuals and companies.



4) Acceleration of digitalisation but capacity building needed

The panel observed that the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the speed of digital transformation. E-commerce and online businesses were already growing quickly in ASEAN prior to the outbreak, but most businesses will now consider e-commerce as a necessity rather than a luxury. The acceleration of digitalisation, however, has brought to fore the digital literacy gap in the market, while some businesses are still playing catch up to digitalisation. The panel suggested that policymakers focus on providing capacity building to MSMEs on how to navigate and adjust to the new business environment, in particular on how to leverage digital technologies.

“The lack of digital literacy has to be addressed. Many of the relief funds in Thailand require registration online or on mobile devices but the truth is, the majority of Thai citizens and businesses are not digital literate. Likewise, entrepreneurs must adapt to the new-normal of meeting the surge in fulfilling grocery and food demand as well as delivery through online platforms. Businesses must act on digital preparedness now in anticipation of the market’s returning to normal,” said Arin Jira.



5) The recovery ahead for ASEAN

In closing, Tan Sri Munir urged ASEAN leaders to deepen ASEAN integration in response to the post-pandemic trade order.

“In the aftermath of COVID-19, globalisation will be diminished. There will be greater regionalisation of the world in which ASEAN is well-placed if it took its chances, and truly established the AEC, that single production base and market long-promised but still fragmented by barriers and nationalist sentiment. The post-COVID-19 economic recovery is entirely in Asean’s hands and in those of its partners in the wider RCEP.”


1 IHS Markit, ‘IHS Markit ASEAN Manufacturing PMI: PMI tumbles to record low in March amid global COVID-19 pandemic’, April 2020.

CARI Captures 450: ASEAN-5 countries projected to grow in 2021



 

ASEAN

ASEAN-5 countries projected to grow in 2021
(15 April 2020) The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has projected strong growth for the ASEAN-5 countries, which are expected to achieve a combined GDP growth of 7.8% in 2021. Malaysia is expected to be the fastest-growing among the ASEAN-5 countries, with a projected growth rate of 9.0% for 2021. The other ASEAN-5 countries are projected to capture robust growth rates as well: Indonesia (8.2%), the Philippines (7.6%), Vietnam (7.0%) and Thailand (6.1%). The latest 2021 IMF projection for Malaysia is higher than Fitch Ratings’ projection of 5.8%. The IMF’s latest forecast expects global growth to contract by -3.0% before rebounding to 5.8% in 2021. However, the international financial institution noted that the rebound in 2021 depends critically on the pandemic fading in the second half of 2020, allowing containment efforts to be gradually scaled back and restoring consumer and investor confidence.

ASEAN

ASEAN rallies against COVID-19
(14 April 2020) The leaders of ASEAN met at the Special ASEAN Summit on COVID-19 via a videoconference chaired by Vietnamese Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc on 14 April 2020. They resolved to further strengthen health cooperation measures to contain the COVID-19 pandemic and protect the people and to intensify cooperation for adequate provision of medicines, essential medical supplies, and equipment, including diagnostic tools, and personal protective equipment. At the meeting, Thai Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha proposed repurposing funds to support efforts to deal with the pandemic. According to a local Indonesian news outlet, part of the existing ASEAN Development Fund will be allocated to set up the new fund. Malaysia also proposed that ASEAN formulate an economic recovery plan post-COVID-19 that focuses not only on the financial aspects but also on social safety net, food security and education.

ASEAN

ASEAN now China’s largest trading partner
(15 April 2020) The ASEAN bloc has replaced the European Union to become China’s largest trading partner in the first quarter of 2020, according to data from the Chinese General Administration of Customs cited by a Chinese online news portal. In the first three months of 2020, total bilateral trade between ASEAN and China rose 6.1% year-on-year to US$140.62 billion despite the COVID-19 outbreak. However, the online news portal pointed out that manufacturing activities in some ASEAN countries were hit hard by the pandemic in March. ASEAN’s purchasing managers’ index (PMI) fell from 50.2 in February to 43.3 in March. The news outlet further stated that China can help the ASEAN supply chain recover.

MALAYSIA

Malaysia agrees to cut crude oil production by 136,000 bpd for May and June in line with OPEC+ pact
(15 April 2020) The Malaysian government agreed to cut its crude oil production by 136,000 bpd for May and June 2020 in line with an OPEC+ record deal which could see 20% of global oil supply being curbed. The Malaysian government welcomed the global supply reduction agreement despite being a small producer and net importer of oil, as it could help stabilise the global oil market and prop up oil prices amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite the cuts, it was critical for the Malaysian government to preserve a favourable investment climate since its upstream market is a liberalised market.

THE PHILIPPINES

Philippine central bank cuts interest rate by 50 basis points in off cycle move
(16 April 2020) The Philippines’ central bank, Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, has cut its key interest rate by 50 basis points in an off-cycle monetary easing move amidst fears of a possible recession in 2020. This will bring the benchmark interest rate to 2.75%, with the country having made 125 basis points worth of cuts this year. The move comes ahead of a scheduled monetary policy announcement on 21 May, and follows a 50 basis point reduction on 19 March. The central bank stated the cut was to encourage lending to various sectors amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. Finance Secretary Carlos Dominguez has said that the Philippine economy could contract by 0.8% or post zero growth in 2020.

THAILAND

Thai central bank to temper borrowing costs amidst massive borrowing by government
(17 April 2020) The Bank of Thailand could adopt unconventional methods to temper bond yields amidst a US$30.6 billion borrowing programme by the government. It is believed that the central bank had studied options such as large scale asset purchase programmes and some forms of yield-curve control. The additional borrowing by the government is more than double the average annual budget deficit of recent years, with concerns over how this will affect liquidity. Thailand has Southeast Asia’s largest local-currency bond market worth US$446 billion at the end of 2019. Its economy is expected to contract by 6.7% in 2020, according to IMF estimates.

INDONESIA

Indonesia records US$743.4 million trade balance surplus in March 2020
(15 April 2020) Indonesia’s trade balance in March 2020 recorded a surplus of US$743.4 million, with exports valued at US$14.09 billion and imports at US$13.35 billion, according to the Central Statistics Agency (BPS). In March, the non-oil and gas trade surplus stood at US$1.7 billion, while the oil and gas sector posted a deficit of US$932 million. Therefore, the trade balance during the January-March 2020 period registered a surplus of US$2.62 billion, with an export value of US$41.79 billion and imports, US$39.17 billion. According to BPS Chief Suhariyanto, the trade surplus from January to March 2020 was a big improvement as compared to the same period in 2019 when a deficit of $62.8 million was recorded.

SINGAPORE

Singapore’s non-oil domestic exports grow by 17.6% year-on-year in March 2020
(17 April 2020) Singapore’s non-oil domestic exports grew by 17.6% year-on-year in March 2020, a substantial jump from the 3.1% year-on-year growth seen in February 2020. On a seasonally adjusted month-on-month basis, Singapore’s non-oil domestic exports rose by 12.8% in March, up from February’s 4.7% decline. Total trade in March grew by 0.7% month-on-month after a 8.6% decline in February. The growth in non-oil domestic exports was attributed to non-electronics such as non-monetary gold, specialised machinery and pharmaceuticals. Exports to the majority of markets increased with the exception of Malaysia, Indonesia, and China.

SINGAPORE, NEW ZEALAND

Singapore, NZ to keep trade lines in essential goods open
(15 April 2020) The trade ministers of Singapore and New Zealand have concluded negotiations to keep trade lines in essential goods open during the COVID-19 outbreak. A declaration on trade in essential goods for the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic was made in a joint statement announced on 15 April. This follows a joint ministerial statement on supply chain connectivity issued by the two countries in March 2020. Under the joint declaration, there will be no tariffs and other trade barriers, including export restrictions. Singapore is expected to receive its first shipment of essential supplies from New Zealand next week. The two countries will also work closely to expedite and facilitate the flow and transit of essential supplies through their respective sea and air ports.

CAMBODIA

Cambodia drops by eight spots in latest Index of Economic Freedom
(17 April 2020) Cambodia’s ranking in the latest Index of Economic Freedom dropped by eight places from 2019. The drop is largely due to lesser investment freedoms, with the country dropping by 10 points in that category from a year earlier. In 2020, Cambodia scored 57.3 points, putting it at the 113th position among 180 countries while the country held the 105th spot in 2019 after posting a score of 56.8 points. The study noted that while economic freedom in Cambodia has been in decline since 2017, its economic growth has been strong with an average of 7.1% over the past five years. The study opined that Cambodia will need to implement deep, broad, and well-institutionalised reforms. The Index of Economic Freedom is co-produced by the Heritage Foundation and the Wall Street Journal.

Mekong Monitor: Thailand’s outlook revised from positive to stable amidst COVID-19 uncertainty


Photo credit: Bangkok Post

 

TRADE, ECONOMY, AND INVESTMENT

 

THAILAND

Thailand’s outlook revised from positive to stable amidst COVID-19 uncertainty
(15 April 2020) S&P Global Ratings has revised its outlook for Thailand from positive to stable amidst the COVID-19 outbreak, pointing to projected “slower political adjustments.” The ratings agency expects Thailand’s political transition under the elected government to be delayed due to coronavirus-induced economic uncertainty. Two political developments that should be observed are the banning of the Future Forward Party and the potential departure of the Democrat Party from the ruling coalition. If there is more certainty about the direction of Thailand’s politics, the ratings agency stated it may decide to raise the ratings while a slower economic recovery and disruptions in Thailand’s political transition would see a downgrade. Thailand’s economy is projected to see a 2.5% contraction and a 5% decline in exports. Measures to alleviate the economic fallout are expected to widen Thailand’s fiscal deficit to 5.5% of GDP, raising net government debt to 31% of GDP in 2020.
Read more>>

THAILAND

Thai Prime Minister calls for gold sellers to practice moderation to avoid cash crunch at gold shops
(15 April 2020) Thai Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-Ocha urged Thais to sell their gold “gradually” to ensure that gold shops do not suffer a cash crunch. This comes amidst a surge in people trying to sell their gold belongings as gold prices hit a seven-year high. On 14 April, the purchase price of gold bars was US$797 (26,050 baht) per baht weight while the selling price was US$802 (26,250 baht). Many sellers cited getting laid off or having their wages cut during the COVID-19 lockdown. The Prime Minister stated that officials are working with gold shops to ensure they have enough money to deal with a surge in sellers. Thailand’s Gold Traders Association chairman Jitti Tangsitpakdee urged people to avoid selling in large quantities due to worries of possible liquidity problems, concerned that some shops may have to shut down temporarily.
Read more>>

THAILAND, MYANMAR

Thailand’s Kasikornbank to expand digital banking services in Myanmar
(16 April 2020) Kasikornbank’s acquisition of a 35% stake in Ayeyarwaddy Farmers Development Bank was approved by Myanmar’s central bank, making it the first foreign commercial bank to acquire a stake in a local lender. The stake is reportedly worth US$40 million. Kasikornbank stated they would leverage upon Ayeyarwaddy Farmers Development Bank’s network of branches in the country to expand digital banking services to both existing customers and unbanked people. The acquisition would help expand its digital banking services and electronic payment systems. Myanmar’s digital banking market has garnered foreign interest in recent years, due to the surge in smartphone penetration among its people. The COVID-19 outbreak has further expanded prospects for both e-commerce and digital banking in the country.
Read more>>

VIETNAM

Exports expected to drop by 21% in first quarter of 2020
(14 April 2020) Vietnam’s total exports are projected to fall by 21% in the first quarter of 2020 as the country’s exporters see declining orders from Europe and the US, according to a Ho Chi Minh City-based supply chain consultancy. Freight forwarders in Vietnam have seen cargo volumes drop by 70% in comparison with pre-coronavirus levels, as many key markets remain under lockdown. Demand is now the biggest challenge for exports, when initially it was supply side issues that affected businesses when the virus broke out. When supply chains were initially affected, it prompted a frantic search for alternative production and transport capacity in Vietnam. However, Vietnams’ own reliance on raw materials and components from China led to delays and production challenges.
Read more>>

VIETNAM, CAMBODIA

Vietnam Airlines to sell its 49% stake in Cambodia Angkor Air
(14 April 2020) Vietnam Airlines is set to sell its 49% stake in Cambodia Angkor Air after the former has been left cash-strapped amidst the COVID-19 outbreak. Vietnam Air is reportedly in advanced talks with potential buyers, including the Cambodian government, which owns the remaining 51% stake. Vietnam Airlines informed investors it has received permission from the Vietnamese government (its majority shareholder) to sell its stake. Established in 2009 as the new flag carrier, Cambodia Angkor Air has reportedly not been profitable. It operates about 10 domestic and foreign routes and has a code-share arrangement with Vietnam Airlines. The Vietnamese carrier halted all international service in late March 2020, and furloughed roughly 10,000 employees (about half its workforce).
Read more>>

 


mekong-monitor-map

About Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS)

The Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS) Economic Programme was launched by the Asian Development Bank in 1992 connecting five developing ASEAN countries, namely Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Vietnam and Thailand, and Chinese provinces of Yunnan and Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous region. The region has some of the most robust economies sharing the Mekong River Basin thanks to its reform and liberalisation. The subregion is growing at a faster pace than the whole of East Asia and the Asia Pacific as the GDP growth rate for 2017 was at 6.4 percent, according to the World Bank. The population at the subregion as of 2016 is at 340 million while the GDP at PPP is at US$3.1 trillion in 2016. In 2015, trading within the region was at US$444 billion.

China-ASEAN Monitor: ASEAN+3 leaders meet online to discuss COVID-19

Photo Credit: VNA/VNS Photo

 

Economy, Investment and Trade

 

ASEAN+3 leaders meet online to discuss COVID-19
(14 April 2020) ASEAN leaders and their three ASEAN partners, namely China, South Korea and Japan, discussed initiatives to strengthen cooperation in the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic. The online ASEAN Special Summit and ASEAN+3 Special Summit on COVID-19 response took place on 14 April and was chaired in Hanoi by Vietnamese Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc. The leaders discussed measures to protect people’s interests and ease socio-economic impacts caused by pandemic, and put forward a post-pandemic recovery plan. ASEAN leaders noted the lessons that could be learned from the way China, South Korea and Japan managed the pandemic. In terms of the economy, the leaders pledged to maintain open markets, expedite the signing of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP), diversify the connectivity of supply sources in and outside the region, and ensure the flow of goods and services, particularly essential medical materials and products.
Read more>>

Cambodia, China conclude second round of FTA negotiations
(11 April 2020) Cambodia and China have wrapped up the second round of negotiations of a free trade agreement (FTA). Held on 10 April, the negotiation meeting was co-chaired by Sok Sopheak, Secretary of State at the Cambodian Ministry of Commerce and Yang Zhengwei, Deputy Director-General of China’s Ministry of Commerce, and held via video conference. Both countries agreed to conclude the remaining issues by May 2020, before the third round of negotiations, scheduled for June 2020. The FTA between Cambodia and China is expected to contribute to the recovery of the two countries which have been impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic. The first round of negotiations was previously held in Beijing in January 2020.
Read more>>

Myanmar trucks stopped at China border crossing due to COVID-19 restrictions
(13 April 2020) Around 300 trucks that transport bananas and watermelons to China daily via a border crossing in the Myanmar town of Lweje near Longchuan County in southwest China’s Yunnan province were not permitted to enter China on 13 April. A media report on 10 April revealed that Chinese authorities have restricted their drivers from entering Myanmar and since 1 April have required Myanmar traders in northern Shan state to pay Chinese drivers 10 yuan each (US$1.40) to transport truckloads of rice and fruit from border crossings to local cargo facilities. Truck drivers say China’s policy of handing over their vehicle keys to Chinese drivers is being enforced at border crossings in Kachin state and they are concerned about their vehicles if this rule is enforced. Myanmar government officials have met with Chinese authorities to try to resolve the issue and come up with alternatives.
Read more>>

Chinese medical team conclude anti-epidemic training in Laos
(11 April 2020) China’s anti-epidemic medical expert team has completed its experience sharing and training programme for central Laos’ backbone staff in hospital, prevention and control departments. According to He Wei, the liaison official of the Chinese expert team, the team has conducted the COVID-19 diagnosis and treatment programme, hospital infection prevention and protection, and epidemiological survey of COVID-19, guidelines for personal protection, among others, for central Laos’ four provincial regions, including three provinces and the capital Vientiane. The team concluded the anti-epidemic training in all the 18 provincial regions in Laos on 11 April. The Lao side expressed gratitude to the Chinese team for dispatching the expert team to assist Laos immediately.
Read more>>

Vietnam restricts exports to China over stringent border controls
(10 April 2020) Due to stringent import measures imposed by China in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, Vietnam will only allow exports through official channels. On 9 April, Its Ministry of Industry and Trade said that the recently imposed more stringent measures were to limit the immigration of people and transport from Vietnam as China seeks to prevent the entry of COVID-19 from outside the country. Border gates between Vietnam and China have not resumed full operations due to protective measures imposed by both countries. As of 8 April, there were nearly 1,700 containers stuck at the Vietnamese side of the border, mostly carrying fruits. The trade ministry will work with Chinese officials to ensure commerce continues under safe conditions. According to ministry estimates, fruit exports from Vietnam to China in the first quarter of 2020 fell 29.4% year-on-year to US$300 million as the pandemic halted normal trade.
Read more>>

How COVID-19 will transform global supply chains and how ASEAN must respond



 

KEY HIGHLIGHTS


    1. The rapid spread of COVID-19 has impacted manufacturing the world over. ASEAN industries in particular are in for a painful 2020 due to supply chain disruptions centering on China.

 

    1. The modern nature of supply chains, with their focus on lean manufacturing and supplier consolidation, has put them at greater risk of disruptions.

 

    1. According to IHS Markit PMI data, ASEAN manufacturers saw their worst month on record in March 2020, due in part to supply chain disruptions impacting factory production and delivery times.

 

    1. There are several scenarios for how the COVID-19 pandemic could play out and its economic ramifications, including a seasonal disruption, prolonged disruption, an uneven rebound, and a global rebound.

 

    1. Multinationals looking to hedge against future supply chain disruptions may look towards diversifying their production bases away from China, or reshoring production back home.

 

  1. ASEAN should respond to these expected shifts in global trade by advocating for greater intra-ASEAN trade and investment, pushing ASEAN towards becoming a single market to increase its competitiveness, recognising public health as a new dimension of global trade, and guarding against any rise in global protectionism by defending the rules-based international order.

 

 

A disruption in supply and demand


As of April 10, 2020, there have been over 1.6 million confirmed cases of the respiratory virus COVID-19 worldwide, along with over 95,000 deaths. The virus has had an unprecedented impact on world economic activity, with many major global economic and financial centres, including New York City, London, Tokyo, Hong Kong and Singapore, under some form of a lockdown or undergoing significant restrictions in mass gatherings and business operations. Travel restrictions have been imposed by over 150 countries, accounting for the vast majority of travel demand.1

After a shutdown and now gradual recovery of Factory Asia, we are now seeing a shutdown of Factory Europe and America, with the impact of the coronavirus outbreak having shifted from the services sector to manufacturing. This has caused shutdowns in heavy industry in the West not seen since the Second World War.2

 

ASEAN manufacturing: the China Factor


2020 promises to be a painful year for ASEAN’s export-orientated economies – many of whom serve as key supply nodes within the intricate regional production networks centring on China. ASEAN serves as a major supplier of intermediate goods and commodities to China, who process them into finished goods for export to the West.

Likewise, much of ASEAN’s own domestic manufacture, from electronics to textiles, depend on Chinese-made components and raw materials. The rapid spread of the coronavirus, and the subsequent lockdowns governments imposed to contain it, thus saw disruptions in global value chains through both demand and supply.

 

The vulnerabilities of modern supply chains


Beyond an over-dependence on China, pundits have pointed to the unique vulnerabilities of modern global supply chains which have been laid bare by the COVID-19 pandemic. Recent attempts by global businesses to reduce supply chain costs through a focus on lean manufacturing, offshoring, and supplier consolidation by concentrating manufacturing while also reducing inventory levels that limit businesses’ reactive capacity in case of disruptions has paradoxically increased overall global supply chain risk. . Supply chains have ultimately become more integrated, but at the same time less flexible.

This was evidently seen in how many businesses were seemingly caught off guard by the pandemic. 71% of businesses surveyed by The Economist in February would state they had no business operations contingency plan in case the outbreak lasted longer than a few weeks.3

 

Freefall of China’s manufacturing sector


The initial outbreak of the coronavirus in Wuhan would have a severe impact on Chinese manufacturing. According to numbers by China’s own National Bureau of Statistics:

  • The Manufacturing Purchasing Managers Index (PMI), a measure of factory activity across the country, plummeted to a record low of 35.7 in February 2020, down from 50.0 the month before (see Figure 1).4
  • The production index in February 2020 was 27.8%, dropping by 23.5% from the month prior, indicating a slowdown in manufacturing production activity.5

 

Supply chains in ASEAN severely disrupted


Like the virus itself, the economic impact has spread quickly to Southeast Asia through the disruption of the supply of raw materials, labor, and sub-assembly components. According to IHS Markit’s PMI data, ASEAN manufacturers saw their worst month on record in March 2020, with the headline PMI falling from 50.2 in February to a record low of 43.4 in March (see Figure 2). 6

Deteriorations were reported in each of the seven constituent economies that IHS Markit covered. The downturn was most marked in Singapore, with the headline figure in March slipping a record 18.1 points month-on-month to 27.7, its lowest score in the eight-year history of the survey (see Figure 3).7

The drop was attributed to deteriorating operating conditions for manufacturing firms, with record declines in production output and new orders in particular driving the downturn. Disruptions in supply chains impacted factory production and caused delays in delivery times.8

 

 

ASEAN industries in trouble


Numerous industries across ASEAN, several of whom are major domestic employers within their respective economies, would report being impacted by supply chains disruptions linked to China. These included:

    • Tech firms in Malaysia’s state of Penang, one of the world’s largest electronics and electrical hubs, warning of disruptions in supplies from China and therefore to their revenue growth outlook. Many of these firms supply major tech multinationals such as Intel, Apple, and Broadcom, and rely on China for as much as 60% of components and materials.9

 

    • Textile firms in Cambodia and Vietnam faced disruptions in the supply of raw materials from China. Cambodia’s garment industry employs some one million full-time workers, and procures some 60% of its textiles from China.10

 

  • Factories in Indonesia have complained of supply disruptions of raw materials, with an estimated 20% to 50% of the raw materials for the country’s factories being sourced from China alone. The government was forced to step in to provide relief measures such as six-month relief from income tax for workers in the manufacturing sector and delays in import and corporate taxes for businesses.11

According to a February 2020 survey by the American Chamber of Commerce in Singapore, a majority of firms in the logistics, manufacturing, and technology sectors stated that the pandemic had impacted their business operations (see Figure 4).

Given Singapore’s position as a regional hub for the larger Asia-Pacific region for many multinationals, the impact on firms in the country is possibly indicative of larger disruptions to regional supply chains.

Supply chain disruptions have not only impacted manufacturers but also those in the services sector. A survey of 150 finance executives from around the world by PricewaterHouse Cooper (PwC) during the week of March 23 concerning the pandemic saw 36% responding that they were considering making adjustments to their supply chains (see Figure 5).

 

How bad can it get?


Global risk intelligence consultancy Control Risks lays out four scenarios for the COVID-19 global pandemic, with focus on the implications for global supply chains (Table 1).12

 

Future implications for global supply chains


In the long term, global businesses hoping to hedge themselves from future supply chain disruptions can respond through two main strategies:

    1. Supply chain diversification: the global pandemic has revealed the inherent risk of firms directing all of their demand for intermediate goods and raw materials to a single source. Companies in the future may decide to diversify their production bases to hedge against future supply shocks, regardless of the immediate cost benefits.

      We may see a greater relocation of production from China to Southeast Asia in light of the pandemic, but as Thai Ambassador to Malaysia H.E. Narong Sasitorn noted in a recent CARI ASEAN Roundtable Series, ASEAN would first have to demonstrate they collectively understand the opportunities being provided to them in order to attract investors.13

      A 2018 study by Nomura identified Malaysia, followed by Thailand and the Philippines, as the biggest potential beneficiaries among select Asian countries of import substitution by US and Chinese firms during the US-China Trade War (see Figure 6).14

      The study similarly identified Vietnam, followed by Malaysia and Singapore, as the most likely Asian countries in diverting production and FDI away from China during the same period (see Figure 6).15

      Both of these findings may be replicated by companies seeking to diversify their sources of production in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, assuming ASEAN leaders can correctly identify the opportunities and take advantage of them. 

       

      *Nomura utilized the Nomura Import Substitution Index (NISI) to identify which Asian countries would benefit the most from Chinese and US import substitutions (e.g. importing from other countries due to tariffs imposed).
      **They also used the Nomura Production Relocation Index (NPRI) to identify which countries would be most successful in diverting production and FDI from China.



    2. Onshoring of production: the exposure of the inherent fragility of modern supply chains may persuade some companies to produce more of their goods locally. The advent of the Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) and the increasing automation of manufacturing has made it more economical to shift production back to developed economies where the costs of labor is less material. This has been referred to as onshoring or near-shoring.

      SHEA Global, an automation technologies consultant, noted that such as artificial intelligence (AI) and augmented reality (AR) will allow future workers in the manufacturing sector to work remotely and thus to continue operations during disruptions, mitigating future workplace health risks in the process.16

      The seventh annual Kearney US Reshoring Index, which compares US manufacturing gross output to the import of manufactured goods from 14 Asian low-cost countries* (LCCs) proves illuminating. The US Reshoring Index is expressed in basis points (1 percent change = 100 basis points). A positive index number indicates net reshoring – the degree by which gross domestic output exceeded imports from the 14 LCCs as compared to the previous year. 17

      The resulting 98-basis point jump in the Kearney Reshoring Index in 2019 is by far the highest yet registered by the index (see figure 7). Kearney attributed this almost exclusively to a collapse in imports from China, which declined by 17% in value terms due to US tariffs. By a substantially increased margin, US companies chose to source more goods domestically rather than import them from the Asian LCC countries. 18

      Kearney argued that COVID-19 will further force companies to rethink their sourcing strategies by factoring in resilience (the ability to foresee and adapt to unforeseen systemic shocks) as a new dimension of global supply chains.19 

 

The path forward for ASEAN


Given the disruptions and projected long-term changes to global supply chains, there are different ways ASEAN can respond:

      • Push for greater intra-ASEAN trade and investments: in light of ongoing fracturings of global supply chains and shifts towards onshoring of manufacturing, ASEAN should seek to hedge themselves in the long term by pushing for greater intra-regional trade and investment. Greater regional connectivity can help strengthen the bloc in an increasingly uncertain trading environment and make the region less dependent on external markets such as China.

 

      • Building a competitive ASEAN single market: for multinationals who seek to diversify their future production bases (instead of producing their goods locally) , many will no doubt turn to Southeast Asia for alternative manufacturing sites. ASEAN must be cognizant of these trends and expedite liberalisation reforms and push ASEAN towards a single market in order to better compete with larger markets such as China and India.

        However, caution must be practised. Even if ASEAN firms were to benefit from import-substitution and production relocation vis-a-vis China, the complexity of modern supply chains means these firms may themselves may be dependent on Chinese supplies of raw materials and sub-assembly components. To put this into better perspective, data from the Carnegie Institute revealed that countries like Vietnam, Philippines, and Indonesia imported a larger proportion of Chinese-made intermediate goods than finished goods (see Figure 8). Most multinational corporations (MNCs) today are often unaware of the full extent of their supply chains below their top tier (direct) suppliers. 20

        There are often no direct contractual relationships between MNCs and their lower tier suppliers. This leads to increased risk and challenges in managing the lower tier suppliers as they are further removed from the MNC’s direct supervision. It will be prudent for firms moving forward to exhaustively map out their supply chains to help determine the full extent of their vulnerabilities to future disruptions. 21 

      • Public health as a new dimension of global trade: in relation to the previous point, the COVID-19 pandemic has added a biological dimension to the political and institutional challenges of contemporary global trade. Future investors may be wary of investing in or trading with countries with inadequate public health infrastructure that would struggle to handle pandemics such as the coronavirus.

        Figures from the World Health Organisation are revealing: the majority of ASEAN Member States with the exception of Vietnam and Cambodia allocated a smaller proportion of their resources towards healthcare compared to the average for lower middle income countries (as defined by the World Bank), and ASEAN collectively allocated lower amounts than upper middle income countries (see Figure 9). This would indicate a lack of focus on public health for many ASEAN countries, which may change post-pandemic.22 



*Current health expenditure as a share of GDP provides an indication on the level of resources channelled to health relative to other uses. It shows the importance of the health sector in the whole economy and indicates the societal priority which health is given measured in monetary terms.
**It should be noted that higher health expenditure does not always produce better health outcomes and values. While Cambodia spends a higher proportion of resources towards healthcare than Singapore, the latter scores higher in terms of life expectancy.


      • Guarding against protectionism: the COVID-19 pandemic arrives on the back of ongoing disruptions to global trade caused by the US-China trade war, China’s economic slowdown and internal shift towards domestic consumption, and the UK’s ongoing and uncertain disengagement from the European Union. Depending on the future course of this pandemic (particularly the economic impact), present public skepticism towards globalization may heighten.

        As middle-power open economies, ASEAN will have to strive harder to defend the global rules-based trading order from which it benefits from. Regional trade agreements such as the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) can serve as multilateral mechanisms to push back against protectionist sentiments, while also bolstering ASEAN centrality and give the region a louder voice in managing great power relations in the region.

 

Conclusion


The rapid spread of COVID-19 has led to significant disruptions in global supply chains, with implications for the economic wellbeing of ASEAN. This is due to both the over-dependence of many global supply chains on China (the first epicentre of the outbreak), as well as the inflexible nature of modern supply chains. There are already indications of the economic fallout of the outbreak in China reaching Southeast Asia, with locally-based manufacturers reporting their worse PMI data on record in March 2020, due in part to supply chain disruptions.

There are ultimately several scenarios of how this pandemic and the economic fallout it will bring will play out, from a swift containment of the virus and supply chains eventually recovering within 2020, to uneven recoveries and an onshoring of production amidst rising protectionist sentiments. Multinational manufacturing firms hoping to hedge against future disruption risks can either choose to diversify their manufacturing bases to other countries or produce more goods locally by taking advantage of automation and fourth-industrial revolution technologies. Recent studies suggest the latter process is already underway.

Expected dramatic changes in global trade and supply chains will demand a response from ASEAN in order to maintain international relevancy. The bloc should respond by advocating for greater intra-ASEAN trade and investment to reduce dependency on external markets, as well as pushing towards a single market in order to attract future investors looking for alternative production bases away from China. ASEAN policymakers will also have to be cognizant of the importance of public health as a new dimension of global trade, and guard vigilantly against any rise in global protectionism through multilateral mechanisms such as RCEP.

 

1World Meters, ‘COVID-19 Coronavirus Pandemic’, accessed on April 3, 2020.
2Bloomberg, ‘Biggest Factory Closing Since World War II Hits U.S., Europe’, March 2020.
3(Webinar) The Economist: Coronavirus outbreak – economic and business implications, February 2020.
4National Bureau of Statistics of China, ‘Purchasing Managers Index for February 2020’, March 2020.
5Ibid.
6IHS Markit, ‘IHS Markit ASEAN Manufacturing PMI: PMI tumbles to record low in March amid global COVID-19 pandemic’, April 2020.
7Ibid.
8Ibid.
9Reuters, ‘In Malaysia’s Silicon Valley, fortunes flip as virus wrecks trade war gains’, March 2020.
10Nikkei Asian Review, ‘Cambodia’s garment industry hangs by a thread’, March 2020.
11 The Star, ‘Covid-19: Indonesia waives income tax for manufacturing workers for six months’, March 2020,
12Control Risks, ‘New global scenarios for COVID-19’, April 2020.
13CIMB ASEAN Research Institute: ‘CARI Viewpoint: ASEAN Roundtable Series on Malaysia-Thailand: Towards Connectivity Beyond Borders’, February 2020.
14Nomura, ‘US-Sino trade friction: not all a lose-lose outcome for Asia’, November 2018.
15Ibid.
16SHEA, ‘COVID-19 and the Workplace Part 1: Global Supply Chain Disruption’, March 2020.
17Kearney, ‘Trade war spurs sharp reversal in 2019 Reshoring Index, foreshadowing COVID-19 test of supply chain resilience’, April 2020.
18Ibid.
*China, Taiwan, Malaysia, India, Vietnam, Thailand, Indonesia, Singapore, Philippines, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Hong Kong, Sri Lanka, and Cambodia.
19Ibid.
20Harvard Business Review, ‘A More Sustainable Supply Chain’, March-April 2020.
21International Finance, ‘Epidemics in China: Reducing global supply chain risks’, March 2020, Harvard Business Review, ‘A More Sustainable Supply Chain’, March-April 2020 issue.




Research Director: Hong Jukhee
Editorial Team: Mohd Imran Said Mohd Shamsunahar, Eleen Ooi Yi Ling, Nor Amirah Mohd Aminuddin

CARI Captures 449: Report shows decline in ASEAN community mobility during COVID-19 pandemic



 

ASEAN

Report shows decline in mobility during COVID-19 pandemic
(29 March 2020) Movement trends of people around the world was recently revealed in Google’s COVID-19 Community Mobility Reports. The reports compare movement trends over time by geography, across six different categories of places. Among ASEAN countries, the trend in all the categories except residential showed a decline when compared to the baseline. Countries with partial lockdowns in place such as Malaysia and the Philippines showed significant drop in all categories except for residential. For instance, in the retail & recreation category, both saw a decline of 81% while visits to transit stations showed a sharp decline at 83% for Malaysia and 82% for the Philippines. The two countries also showed sharp reductions in movements to the workplaces, with both seeing a more than 50% decrease. The movement to residential places showed an upward trend for all ASEAN countries, with the highest increase of 31% evident in Malaysia, followed by 26% in the Philippines. The analysis of location data from billions of Google users’ phones were revealed to help health authorities assess if people are abiding with movement control orders and similar orders issued across the world to rein in the virus.

THE PHILIPPINES

Trade deficit narrows as virus fears keep factories shut
(8 April 2020) A sharp decline in imports narrowed the Philippines’ trade gap in February 2020, the government reported on 8 April, an indication that COVID-19 fears are already crippling the country’s growth engines amid falling demand and tepid economic activity. According to the Philippine Statistics Authority, the country posted a trade deficit of US$1.66 billion in February, which was 39.4% smaller than the US$2.73 billion trade deficit recorded a year ago. A closer look revealed that imports fell 11.6% year-on-year in February to US$7.06 billion due to lower purchases of capital goods (-16.18%), raw materials (-8.65%), consumer goods (-9.45%) and mineral fuels (-12.03%), including petroleum crude. Shipments from major trading partner China fell 43.83%. On the flip side, exports posted an annual growth rate of 2.8% to US$5.4 billion. A prominent economist said the country’s shrinking trade deficit will likely persist in the coming months as businesses and factories remain shut in the main island of Luzon.

MALAYSIA

COVID-19 cases cross the 4,000 mark, new sub-cluster detected in Negeri Sembilan
(8 April 2020) Malaysia reported another 156 COVID-19 cases on 8 April, pushing the total number of cases past 4,000 and the number of deaths to 65. The total number of cases had already gone past 3,000 on 2 April. With 4,119 infections as of 8 April, Malaysia remains the worst-hit country in Southeast Asia. According to Health Ministry director-general Noor Hisham Abdullah, 166 more patients have recovered, which brings the total number of patients discharged as of 8 April to 1,487. He also revealed a new COVID-19 sub-cluster was discovered in Rembau, in the state of Negeri Sembilan, and it was linked to the Sri Petaling event. One of the participants of the Sri Petaling event had later attended a school meeting in Rembau. Twenty-seven people have now tested positive for the novel coronavirus, with two undergoing intensive care. Malaysia is currently under the Movement Control Order until 14 April, whereby people are required to stay at home and only essential services are allowed to operate.

MALAYSIA

Economy projected to grow by 5.8% in 2021
(9 April 2020) Fitch Ratings has affirmed Malaysia’s long-term foreign-currency Issuer Default Rating (IDR) at “A-”, with a revised outlook from stable to negative. It also projected Malaysia’s economy to grow by 5.8% in 2021. Malaysia’s government had recently launched a US$60.4 billion economic stimulus package, which is expected to add 2.9% points to its 2021 GDP growth. Malaysia’s Finance Minister Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Aziz stated that Malaysia had entered the pandemic “from a position of strength,” which included a healthy financial system, strong domestic institutional investors, adequate buffers, and robust policy frameworks. The government’s medium-term fiscal strategy will be issued together with the 2021 Budget in October 2020. He also noted that 96% of the government’s debt is issued in ringgit, and therefore not subject to currency fluctuations.

MALAYSIA, UK

Malaysia and UK discuss COVID-19 and cooperation in trade and investment
(9 April 2020) Malaysia and the UK discussed matters concerning COVID-19 and the need for broader bilateral cooperation. The British High Commissioner to Malaysia, Charles Hay, stated that the High Commission had been helping British nationals return to the UK, and also raised the issue of British nationals with work permits or long-term visit passes who are stuck outside Malaysia during the latter’s Movement Control Order (MCO). There are approximately 8,000-10,000 British nationals residing in Malaysia, including work permit holders and those who live in the country under the Malaysia My Second Home programme. The High Commissioner also expressed concern over foreign companies and manufacturers operating under limited time or workforce caps, due to the impact it may have on their orders (especially for essential medical equipment). Britain is also setting up a Joint Committee on Trade and Investment Cooperation with Malaysia, and hopes to pursue a Dialogue Partner status with ASEAN.

INDONESIA

Thousands of workers across Indonesia laid-off due to COVID-19 outbreak
(8 April 2020) Tens of thousands of workers across Indonesia have lost their jobs due to the economic impact brought upon by the COVID-19 pandemic. In Central Java, 24,249 workers have been laid off with 191 companies employing 148,791 workers affected by the outbreak. In West Java, its Manpower and Transmigration Agency recorded that 34,365 workers have been put on leave, 14,053 have been furloughed, while 5,047 have been laid off. In North Sulawesi, the Transmigration and Manpower Agency recorded 1,275 workers in the province that have been laid off, while 2,576 have been furloughed. A total of 262 companies across the region report that they have closed down because of the outbreak. According to Central Java Governor Ganjar Pranowo, the government will seek solutions for workers who have been laid off, one of which is the pre-employment card. “We have been allocated 421,705 slots for the pre-employment cards. So far, only 19,000 people have registered, less than 5% of the allocated slots,” he said.

INDONESIA

COVID-19 adds new worry for Indonesia’s debt-saddled state-owned enterprises
(9 April 2020) The COVID-19 pandemic has added a new worry for Indonesia’s debt-saddled state-owned enterprises (SOEs), with a slump in revenue and credit crunches caused by the surge of the dollar pushing some closer to the risk of default. As of the third quarter of 2019, state-owned firms had amassed a combined debt of US$98 billion (a growth of 15% from the previous year). Many of Indonesia’s SOE’s have binged on debt for years, and many face debt-repayment issues amidst accusations of corruption and mismanagement. SOEs have also been racking up foreign debt as well, which has boosted their funding costs with the dollar surging now. Indonesia’s new SOE minister Erick Thohir has pledged to liquidate firms which fail to contribute to the country’s economic performance.

MYANMAR

Myanmar attracts over US$2 billion in foreign investment in first half of FY 2019/2020
(9 April 2020) Myanmar had attracted some US$2.73 billion from permitted foreign companies in the first half of the FY 2019/2020, which started from 1 October 2019 till 31 March 2020. Within this period, the Myanmar Investment Commission (MIC) gave the go-ahead to 147 foreign investment enterprises. The power sector attracted the most investment with over US$1 billion, followed by the real estate and manufacturing sectors. From FY 1988/1989 to FY 2019/2020, a total of 1,984 foreign enterprises invested capital worth over US$84.5 billion. Singapore, China, and Thailand are the top three investors into Myanmar. The Yangon region attracts some 60% of investments from both home and abroad, followed by the Mandalay region at 30%.

SINGAPORE

Singapore enters month-long lockdown
(7 April 2020) Singapore’s usually bustling business district was almost deserted on 7 April as most workplaces were closed to stem the spread of the COVID-19 coronavirus after a surge in cases. The city-state has won praise for using a tough regime of testing and tracing contacts of the sick to keep its outbreak largely in check, but has seen a jump in new infections in recent days. While authorities previously resisted the kind of drastic measures seen in worse-hit countries, Manpower Minister Josephine Teo announced on 3 April that all workplaces except for those providing essential services and those able to operate remotely were to be suspended from 7 April to 4 May during a month-long “circuit breaker” campaign. Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong urged Singaporeans to do their part to support healthcare professionals by staying at home and complying with the enhanced measures put in place. The city-state reported 66 more COVID-19 cases on 6 April, bringing its total so far to 1,375, including six deaths.

CAMBODIA

Government issues order banning majority of travel within the country for a week
(9 April 2020) The Cambodian government issued an order banning most internal travel for a week in order to contain the spread of COVID-19. The ban came into effect on 10 April, and will last until 16 April. The order, signed by Prime Minister Hun Sen, comes ahead of Cambodia’s new year holiday, a time when many people visit their families in the countryside. While people will be allowed to travel within the capital of Phnom Penh, travel into and out of the city will be barred. Residents will also be prevented from travelling between districts and provincial borders. Those exempted from the order include those transporting food, government officials, military officials, emergency service workers, and those who work in waste disposal. The travel lockdown comes amidst an emergency law likely to be approved by parliament in the coming days.